Start with the question, not the method
Nondestructive testing, or NDT, examines material and welds without damaging them. A quote is only useful if it answers a question you can state, such as whether a weld is sound after fabrication, whether a vessel wall has thinned in service, or whether a surface has cracks. Say what is being inspected, why now, and what decision the result drives, because the answer sets the method and the report.
Give providers the drawings, material, condition and any earlier inspection records. Say whether this is a one-time job, a shutdown scope or a recurring program. A provider quoting a repeat program can price differently from one quoting a single visit, so state which you mean and how firm the schedule is.
Which method fits which question
These are starting points for the conversation. The right method depends on the material, the flaw you are worried about and the access you have. Ask each provider to explain why it chose its method and what that method cannot detect. Where two methods could answer the question, ask for both to be priced as options so you can compare cost against what you learn.
| Method | Usually chosen to answer | What to confirm with the provider |
|---|---|---|
| Visual inspection | Is there visible damage, misalignment or a surface defect? | Who defines what counts as a defect, and whether photographs are included |
| Ultrasonic testing | How much wall remains, and is there a flaw inside the material? | Surface condition needed, and whether results are spot readings or a mapped area |
| Radiographic testing | Is there an internal flaw in a weld or casting? | Exclusion zone, working hours and who controls the area during exposure |
| Magnetic particle testing | Are there surface or near-surface cracks in magnetic steel? | Surface cleanliness required and whether the method suits your material |
| Liquid penetrant testing | Are there surface-breaking cracks in non-porous material? | Cleaning and drying time, and temperature limits for the product used |
| Eddy current testing | Are there surface flaws or tube wall changes? | Which components the method suits and how results are recorded |
Access and surface preparation
Many NDT delays come from access, not the test itself. Decide who supplies scaffolding, lifts, rope access, insulation removal, cleaning and coating removal, and who takes the item out of service and makes it safe to work on. Ask providers to state what they assume you have done, because a quote built on a clean, accessible surface changes the moment the crew arrives and finds otherwise.
- Scaffold, lift or rope access: who supplies it and who inspects it.
- Insulation, coating or scale removal, and reinstatement afterward.
- Isolation, lockout and permits for the work area, and who holds them.
- Power, lighting and a clean, clear area for the inspection equipment.
- When the item is released to the inspector, and what happens if release is late.
Technician qualification
Ask what qualification level the technicians hold for each method and which body issued it. Industry programs rate technicians by level, and the level affects who may perform a test, who may interpret it and who may sign the report. Ask for evidence that is current at the time of work, and confirm whether your site or client requires a specific program.
Ask who supervises the crew, who reviews results before the report is issued, and whether the person who interprets the data is on site or remote. Confirm your own site orientation and safety requirements for visiting crews, and whether the provider holds the access credentials your site demands.
Acceptance criteria and who sets them
A test finds indications. Acceptance criteria decide which ones matter. They usually come from the code, specification or client procedure that governs the item, not from the inspection provider. Name the governing document in your enquiry, or say plainly that you have none and want the provider's recommendation, then confirm that recommendation with your engineer.
Ask what happens to a rejected result: who decides whether to repair, retest or run a further assessment, and who pays for retesting after a repair. Quotes that stay silent on this leave you arguing over scope at the moment the result lands.
Reporting format and turnaround
Specify what you need to receive: a field summary the same day, a formal report, raw data files, photographs, calibration records and a marked-up drawing showing test locations. Ask for the report format, the file type and who reviews it before release. Ask how soon after the work you receive each item, because a provider that finishes quickly but reports slowly can hold up your own close-out.
Agree how results reach you when an indication needs a quick decision. A crew that finds a serious indication late on a Friday should know who to call, and you should know who at the provider can interpret it. Put the contact chain and the expected response in writing before the work starts.
- Whether the report is a summary of results or a full record with raw readings.
- Whether it is signed, and by whom.
- How rejected results are communicated: immediately by phone or only in the report.
- How long records are kept and how you can retrieve them later.
Standby and call-out terms
Standby is the time a crew waits for access, a permit, a clearance or a repair. Ask how it is charged, whether a minimum applies on a call-out, and whether travel and mobilization to a remote site are billed separately. Ask what counts as weather or client delay, and how a short-notice call-out differs from a scheduled visit. Write the answers into the quote so they cannot be argued later.
- Whether a minimum charge applies on every call-out, however short the visit.
- Whether travel time and mobilization are billed from the provider's base or from the last site.
- Who can authorize extra work on site, and how that authorization is recorded.
- How weather delays, late access and cancelled visits are charged.
How quotes end up not comparable
- Quotes price different methods for the same question, so the totals cannot be compared.
- Surface preparation is assumed in one quote and priced in another.
- Acceptance criteria are left unnamed, so a rejected result becomes a dispute.
- Report format and turnaround are not stated, and close-out waits on paperwork.
- Standby is discovered on the invoice because the quote never defined it.
This guide is general buying guidance for a conversation with a provider. It is not engineering, legal or safety advice. Confirm current regulatory requirements with the regulator for your province.